Battery or hydrogen vehicles?

Are they fully sustainable? And which is the more sustainable?

Fossil fuels are an environmental disaster. Petroleum in either liquid or gaseous form, while producing a little less carbon dioxide per kilogram of fuel burned than coal, also results in serious air pollution.

At the time of writing this page, late 2020, it was clear that emission-free battery-electric and hydrogen-fuelcell-electric vehicles will soon be replacing fossil fuel powered vehicles (ICE, internal combustion engine vehicles). It also seems likely that both will be able to compete economically with ICE powered vehicles. In regard to their sustainability both have advantages and disadvantages.

A significant factor is that some of the world's more responsible governments were starting to write an end date to ICE powered vehicles into law.

While replacing ICE powered vehicles with renewably powered vehicles will be a great step forward, we must be careful that it will be as environmentally responsible as possible.

This page is very much a layman's view of the situation. I hope to update it as the technologies develop.


This page was started 2020/12/31
Contact: David K. Clarke – ©
 


This is a work
in progress




Wind farms such as this produce sustainable electricity
Wind farm
Photo of Clements Gap Wind Farm, Mid-North South Australia


Electricity generated by solar or wind power can be used directly to charge vehicle batteries or it can be used to produce hydrogen which can then provide energy for vehicles and other purposes.

 
The recyclability of wind turbine blades is problematic but they do have a long life. Turbines and turbine blades are most often disposed of because they have been superseded by larger ones. As the technology matures wind turbines and turbine blades should have even longer lives.
While the burning of fossil fuels is a proven disaster we must be careful to not replace one unsustainable technology with another. There seems little doubt that wind power is sustainable and that solar photo-voltaic and solar thermal power are sustainable.

But if either battery-electric or hydrogen-electric cars are to be sustainable either the batteries and fuel cells must have very long lives or they must be recyclable and be recycled.



Advantages

Battery-electric-vehicles – advantages

Efficiency

Little energy is lost in the charging and discharging of batteries.

Integration

The batteries in electric vehicles could be integrated into home power systems and into national grids when the vehicle is plugged in.



Hydrogen-fuel-cell-electric vehicles – advantages

Hydrogen can be stored for later use

Electricity itself can't be stored, it must be used as it is generated, but it can be used to generate hydrogen when generation exceeds consumption. Hydrogen has a great many uses; including for many of the same uses as natural gas. It is not easy to store, but it can be combined with nitrogen to form ammonia which is easy to store and export; ammonia has many industrial uses and the hydrogen in it can be recovered.

Recycling

According to Ballard, who apparently manufacture fuel-cells, they are recyclable and the valuable metals can be recovered. Ballard claims that their products meet the relevant European waste electronic equipment (EWWW) directive.



Disadvantages

Battery-electric-vehicles – disadvantages

By far the leading form of battery for battery-electric-vehicles (BEVs) at the time of writing is one of the variations on a lithium battery. Typically, lithium batteries use, in addition to lithium, substantial amounts of cobalt.

Mining

Lithium mining
Lithium is not a plentiful element. In Chile and Argentina (the world's second and forth biggest producers of lithium) mining is done in salars with serious associated environmental problems. While China is not the biggest producer of lithium it is one of the biggest. Considering the current belligerent government in that country it is undesirable to rely it.
Cobalt mining
At the time of writing much of the cobalt mining was taking place in third-world countries that had poor safety standards for miners and poor environmental standards for mining.

Jonathan Watts writing for The Guardian, 2019/12/18, published an article titled 'How the race for cobalt risks turning it from miracle metal to deadly chemical' that outlined a number of problems associated with cobalt mining, which had increased "more than sevenfold between 2008 and 2015 with an increasingly evident impact".

Recycling

At the time of writing, some of the lithium in a lithium battery can be recovered on recycling, but:
  • It is often not recycled because it is cheaper to mine new lithium;
  • If a lithium battery is recycled only some fraction of the lithium is recovered;
  • The lithium recovered from a lithium battery is not sufficiently pure for use in making new batteries.
Recycling is not expected to become a major source of lithium until at least 2030, partly because significant quantities of old lithium batteries are not expected to be available until then.



Hydrogens-fuel-cell-electric vehicles – disadvantages

Hydrogen production

I believe that the production of hydrogen from renewable electricity is only about 30% efficient.

Vehicle efficiency

I believe that the production of electricity from hydrogen in a fuel cell is only about 30% efficient.



Questions

As of the time of writing I believe that there is very little recycling of lithium batteries and the lithium recovered when they are recycled is not sufficiently pure for use in making new batteries. It seems to be cheaper to mine new lithium than to recycle old batteries.

I don't know anything about the recycling of the cobalt that makes up a large proportion of lithium batteries.





Related pages

Related pages on external sites...

There are pages on the internet relating to this subject that can be found using searches such as "Battery or fuel cell vehicles, which are the more sustainable?"

Battery electric vehicles

Are Lithium Ion Batteries Compatible With a Sustainable Future?

Lithium mining: What you should know about the contentious issue.

Fuel-cell electric vehicles

Fuel cell recycling and platinum recovery; Ballard.
"With many years of fuel cell manufacturing experience, Ballard Power Systems, Inc. has developed industry leading processes designed to minimize the energy intensity and environmental impact of product production. At the end of a product’s useful life, processes ensure the efficient recovery of highly valuable precious metals and minimize waste entering the landfill."